23 Underrated Christmas Movies That Deserve a Spot in Your Rotation

Collette ReitzDeputy Editor, Special Projects
Collette ReitzDeputy Editor, Special Projects
Working across AT Media brands, I see through the completion of large-scale editorial projects from their inception. I've worked as an editor in digital media for nearly seven years, covering food and trending news at Elite Daily before coming to ATM. I love using em dashes and running along the Chicago lakefront.
updated 1 day ago
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
THE FAMILY STONE, Rachel McAdams, Diane Keaton, Sarah Jessica Parker, 2005, TM & Copyright (c) 20th Century Fox Film Corp. All rights reserved.
Credit: ©20th Century Fox/Courtesy Everett Collection

Hosting a holiday movie marathon is one of the most traditional (and fun!) activities you can do in November and December, and it’s a great excuse to hang with your roommates and friends. Sure, you need the classics, like The Holiday and Home Alone, but what about when you’re done watching Kevin McCallister craftily save his family’s home from intruders? That’s when you turn to the underrated Christmas movies you forgot about or didn’t even realize qualify as Christmas movies. 

From a Lindsay Lohan instant classic on Netflix, to a star-studded 2005 dramedy, to a rom-com about an engagement ring mix-up set in New York at Christmastime, there are so many cinematic gems waiting to be added to your lineup.

Underrated Christmas Movies

Our Little Secret (2024) 

Lindsay Lohan returns to the Netflix Christmas world in this movie where she stars as Avery, a consultant who goes with her boyfriend, Cameron, to his family’s house for Christmas. Things get messy when she discovers that her ex-almost-fiancé, Logan, is dating Cameron’s sister Cassie, and no one knows Avery and Logan used to date and nearly got engaged a decade ago — and Avery and Logan want to keep it that way. It’s got everything you want in a rom-com: fake smiles, awkward family dinners, and a little bit of blackmail.

Where to watch: Netflix

Something from Tiffany’s (2022)

A case of two men accidentally swapping little blue boxes leads to them navigating some big questions in their respective relationships during the holiday season in New York. 

The real love story kicks off when Ethan, who lost a Tiffany engagement ring in the switch, meets Rachel, who’s dating Gary and accidentally receives the ring in the swap. Rachel, who has no idea Gary didn’t buy the ring and it wasn’t meant for her, gets to know Ethan after inviting him to her bakery, and the pair form an undeniable connection. It’s a sweet, funny film that’ll definitely get you in the holiday spirit 

Where to watch: Prime Video 

Credit: Hulu

Happiest Season (2020)

Kristen Stewart and Dan Levy star in this film where meeting the parents goes slightly wrong when Abby (Stewart) finds out her girlfriend, Harper, has been keeping their relationship a secret from her mom and dad. The couple poses as roommates for the weekend and navigates family holiday tensions. Schitt’s Creek fans will be happy to see Abby’s best friend, Adam (Levy), show up to provide some moral support and comic relief.

Where to watch: Hulu

Jingle Jangle: A Christmas Journey (2020)

A history of stolen inventions and heartbreak leads to Journey, a young girl who’s also an inventor, visiting her grandfather, Jeronicus Jangle, in the days leading up to Christmas. While staying with Jeronicus, Journey finds an old toy, The Buddy 3000, that was dreamed up by her mom, Jessica. Journey gets it working, but Buddy is stolen by Gustafson, a toy tycoon who also stole Jeronicus’ other ideas. The family works together to finally right the wrongs.

Where to watch: Netflix

Klaus (2019)

This animated feature is set in 19th-century Norway and centers on Jesper, the son of Norway’s postmaster general. Jesper is supposed to train to be a postman, but he seems to prefer a more pampered life. His father sends him to a faraway town, where Jesper needs to set up a post office, or he’ll be cut off from his dad’s money. The holiday cheer starts as soon as Jesper meets Klaus, a woodworker who specializes in toys.

Where to watch: Netflix

Let It Snow (2019)

The entire movie takes place after a snowstorm hits on Christmas Eve. Based on a 2008 novel by John Green, Lauren Myracle, and Maureen Johnson, this movie is peppered with teenage love stories (including one with a pop star!), plenty of comedic relief, and quite a few problems that need to be solved in 93 minutes. 

Where to watch: Netflix

Noelle (2019) 

Anna Kendrick plays Noelle Kringle, Santa’s daughter, who finds herself trying to save Christmas after the new Santa in training, her brother (Bill Hader), completely panics and disappears days before the big night. That leads Noelle to Phoenix, Arizona, of course, to look for him. As Noelle navigates life away from the North Pole, she realizes she might also be ready to take on the role of Santa, and her optimism and hijinks make the movie irresistibly sweet without being saccharine. And hello, it’s Anna Kendrick! 

Where to watch: Disney+

A Bad Moms Christmas (2017)

This movie is filled with big names and a lot of family dynamics. Amy (Mila Kunis), Kiki (Kristen Bell), and Carla (Kathryn Hahn) resume their roles in this Bad Moms sequel. Amy, Kiki, and Carla have their own moms — Ruth, Sandy, and Isis, respectively — in town for the holidays and navigate their oftentimes tenuous relationships with them while celebrating the holiday.

Where to watch: Peacock, Hulu, Roku

The Night Before (2015)

Another film stacked with stars: Childhood friends (Joseph Gordon-Levitt, Seth Rogen, and Anthony Mackie), who reunite on Christmas Eve every year, celebrate their last holiday shindig with a night to remember. Centered on getting to The Nutcracker ballet in New York City, the movie takes some wild turns before ending with a rushed cab ride to the hospital for the birth of Isaac’s (Rogen) first baby.

Where to watch: Starz, Tubi

Snow Bride (2013)

The plot of this Hallmark movie is, of course, a little out there: Greta, a tabloid reporter, picks up her friend’s wedding dress, quickly pivots to driving to Big Bear to follow a lead on a story, and gets her car stuck in a snowstorm. She puts on the dress to stay warm, gets rescued by Ben, the subject of her potential story, and celebrates Christmas with him and his family under false pretenses, as one does. There’s a little fake dating, some revenge — Ben’s brother brings home Ben’s ex-girlfriend as his new fling — and plenty of holiday happenings.

Where to watch: Hallmark+

Rise of the Guardians (2012) 

This is traditionally a kids’ movie, but it’s a holiday favorite. Full of fun and set around so many major holidays, the movie takes place in the winter and centers on Santa Claus and Jack Frost, who join forces with other holiday mascots to fight the evil boogeyman. It’s part fantasy, part holiday magic, and all heart. 

Where to Watch: Peacock, HBO Max

Arthur Christmas (2011)

The other animated pick on this list focuses on the story of Arthur, Santa’s younger son. A missing present leads to Arthur trying to deliver a gift himself, with the help of a definitely not up-to-date sleigh and his Grandsanta. Arthur’s approach is less laser-focused than that of Santa and Steve, Arthur’s older brother, who is basically the head of Christmas operations. The movie shows that maybe there’s more than one way to get all those presents to the kids.

Where to watch: Pluto, Apple TV (Rent or Buy)

The Family Stone (2005)

You will laugh and cry while watching this film. The cast is also stacked, starring Diane Keaton, Sarah Jessica Parker, Rachel McAdams, and more. Everett Stone brings his girlfriend, Meredith (Parker), to his family’s home in New England for Christmas, where the house is packed, and there are lots of opinions about their relationship. As the family dynamics play out against the backdrop of an idyllic, snowy Christmas, Meredith invites her sister (Claire Daines) to join her for the holiday, leading to an emotional twist you’ll be rooting for.

Where to watch: Hulu, Prime Video

Christmas with the Kranks (2004)

You know Tim Allen as Santa Claus, but in this movie he’s a middle-aged dad who wants to go on a Christmas cruise with his wife (Jamie Lee Curtis). His Christmas boycott quickly turns into a holiday decorating rush job when their daughter surprises them by coming home. The “free Frosty” scene is something you’ll never forget.

Where to watch: HBO Max

The Santa Clause 2 (2002)

If you’re a fan of the 1994 film, you’ll love the sequel (maybe even more than the original!). Scott Calvin, who is now Santa Claus, learns that his son, Charlie, is on the naughty list. Calvin also has to find a wife before Christmas Eve to keep being Santa. With new characters like Curtis, the number two elf, and Toy Santa, a replica who watches over the North Pole while Calvin is helping Charlie, this sequel takes everything you love about The Santa Clause to the next level. Plus, there’s a hilarious date scene that will make “Man, I Feel Like Some Christmas!” your next earworm.

Where to watch: Disney+

The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)

As you’d expect from the title, this movie tells Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol with the Muppets. Kermit the Frog stars as Bob Cratchit, Miss Piggy is his wife, Emily, and Robin the Frog plays their son, Tiny Tim. Michael Caine plays Ebenezer Scrooge, and you see the classic holiday story play out with your favorite Muppets and original songs like “One More Sleep ’til Christmas” and “It Feels Like Christmas.”

Where to watch: Disney+

Unexpected Christmas Movies

The Holdovers (2023)

Cozy holiday settings are key for a Christmas movie, and The Holdovers delivers in a big way, set over winter break in the 1970s at a New England boarding school. A trio made up of Angus Tully, Barton Academy teacher Paul Hunham, and Mary Lamb, the school’s cook, drives the heart of the story. It follows a few students who couldn’t go home for the break, leaving one student, Angus, on campus for Christmas. While there are plenty of emotional scenes, the film adds levity at just the right moments.

Where to watch: Peacock

The Holidate (2020)

Technically, this movie covers a lot of holidays, but it starts and ends on Christmas. Emma Roberts stars as Sloane, who meets Jackson in line at the mall while returning gifts and — after their respective disastrous Christmases — they strike a deal to be each other’s dates for every holiday until one of them gets a real partner. The fake-dating and enemies-to-lovers tropes that unfold are predictable, but Roberts and Luke Bracey, who plays Jackson, have such great chemistry that you won’t even care.

Where to watch: Netflix

Little Women (2019)

Another film that goes beyond Christmas, but starts with the holiday. The March sisters celebrate Christmas during the Civil War, bonding over their hopes for the future rather than the material gifts they couldn’t afford. At their mother’s suggestion, they even bring their Christmas breakfast to their neighbors, the Hummel family, who don’t have anything. To add to the holiday merriment, they return home from their good deed to a Christmas surprise, thanks to their neighbor.

Where to watch: Hulu

Last Holiday (2006)

The holiday in the title refers to a vacation rather than the holiday season, but it still takes place during Christmastime and culminates on New Year’s Eve. Georgia (Queen Latifah) is mistakenly diagnosed with a terminal brain condition, and she decides to spend her money on living out her dreams. That includes a first-class vacation to the Czech Republic, where she treats herself to designer clothes and lavish meals, until a twist at the end of the film makes Georgia reevaluate her plans.

Where to watch: Paramount+, Pluto TV

Bridget Jones’s Diary (2001)

One of the first scenes in the movie shows Mark (Colin Firth) wearing a Rudolph sweater, and one of the last scenes involves a snowman sweater, so I believe that automatically qualifies it as a Christmas movie. The film follows Bridget (Renée Zellweger) as she attempts to change some aspects of her life over the course of a year, which includes two romances — Mark and Daniel (Hugh Grant) — and a kiss outside in the snow that could certify this as a holiday movie on its own.

Where to watch: Paramount+, Pluto TV

While You Were Sleeping (1995)

Rom-com queen Sandra Bullock stars in this ’90s classic that opens on Christmas Day in Chicago. Lucy (Bullock) works as a CTA token collector when a rider, Peter, gets pushed onto the tracks and falls into a coma. Lucy is mistaken for his fiancée at the hospital and becomes intertwined with his family, especially Peter’s brother, Jack. A series of misunderstandings and meet-cute moments lead to a very eventful New Year’s Day.

Where to watch: Disney+

Die Hard (1988)

I couldn’t leave out the film that has people constantly asking, “Is Die Hard a Christmas movie?” It’s set in Los Angeles on Christmas Eve, where NYPD detective John McClane is trying to patch things up with his estranged wife. Things take a stressful turn at their holiday party when everyone in the building — except McClane — is held hostage by Hans Gruber and his criminal associates. McClane takes on Gruber and the others, trying to free his wife and everyone inside. There’s no caroling and tree-trimming, but there’s a festive soundtrack and intermittent Christmas vibes.

Where to watch: Hulu, Prime Video

Collette Reitz

Deputy Editor, Special Projects

I've worked in digital media for more than seven years — first as a writer, and then as a weekend and full-time editor. I began as a daily trending news writer for Elite Daily and then expanded my coverage as an editor into tech, food, social media, health, current events, and politics. I've collaborated with colleagues to create many exciting packages throughout my career, like Elite Daily's Money Issue, which aimed to help Gen Z better understand their personal finances. More recently, I helped launch Apartment Therapy and The Kitchn's "Happy Hosting!" vertical, packed with clever solutions for making holiday celebrations less stressful. I've also covered exciting product launches, including an Apple iPhone reveal in Cupertino, California. I've been lucky enough to interview accomplished individuals, including former WNBA star Sue Bird, Olympic gymnast Aly Raisman, and the iconic Dolly Parton.What I love most about digital media is connecting with readers. My goal is always to create well-researched content that impacts someone's day, whether that's offering practical solutions and reliable information or just providing a laugh with a well-placed pop-culture reference.

Follow Collette
Get to know Collette Reitz
Related ContentSee All