This Limited-Edition Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Is My New Favorite (It’s the Two Best Desserts!)

Ali Domrongchai
Ali Domrongchai
Ali Domrongchai, a Southern-raised, Brooklyn-based food writer, grew up around her family's Thai restaurant that sparked her initial love for food. (Fun fact: her grandparents briefly ran a Thai grocery store in the 70s). In this space, her curiosity on the role that food plays…read more
published Aug 23, 2025
We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.
Package of Reese's Oreo miniature cups
Credit: Ali Domrongchai

A few weeks ago Oreo and Reese’s broke the internet with news of a collaboration of delicious proportions. At The Kitchn, we’re big fans of both Reese’s and Oreo, as well as their many collaborations (Selena Gomez and Post Malone Oreos and Reese’s Betty Crocker brownies come to mind). But this latest team-up, which has resulted in two — yes, two — limited-edition products, may be the most exciting of all.

We already tried (and adored) the new Oreo Reese’s Cookies (which feature a Reese’s peanut butter filling sandwiched between two chocolate cookies), but the brands have also released new limited-edition Reese’s Oreo Cups that’ll hit shelves early September. I got a first try — here’s my full review. (Spoiler alert: You’re going to want to try it ASAP.) 

Credit: Ali Domrongchai

What You Should Know About Reese’s Oreo Cups 

While the new Oreo Reese’s Cookies are expected to be part of the brand’s permanent line-up, the Reese’s Oreo Cups (the names can be a bit confusing) are limited-edition. They feature layers of Reese’s peanut butter with Oreo cookie crumbles encased in a milk chocolate base and white cream on top. The cups will be available in King Size, Standard Size, and Miniature Cups. 

Credit: Ali Domrongchai

While the internet has been buzzing over this release, shoppers have to wait a bit longer to try them for themselves (but they are worth the wait!). The cups officially hit shelves nationwide in September and will be available for pre-sale online starting August 18. 

My Honest Review of Reese’s Oreo Cups 

The Reese’s Oreo Cups are a culinary feat. They’re a joy to look at — with layers of peanut butter, chocolate, white cream, and Oreo crumbs — and they taste even better. It’s all the best parts of a Reese’s (that classic chocolate-peanut butter goodness) combined with the satisfying chocolate crunch of an Oreo.

Credit: Ali Domrongchai

Naturally I wanted to share the wealth, so I put them out in the office for my coworkers to try. Mara, our director of groceries and shopping, took one bite and immediately said, “Wow, this is fun!” She added that it has an excellent “peanut butter-to-chocolate ratio” (I agree) and said that she would gladly eat the rest of the bag.

Our Culinary Producer Rachel felt similarly, and raved that the “peanut butter is plentiful and the crunch from the Oreo is just divine.” A few other coworkers swarmed around the cups, and we collectively agreed that this is Reese’s best collaboration in a long, long time. 

Sign up for the presale: Reese’s Oreo Cups 

Are you excited for the new collaboration? Tell us about it in the comments below.

This post originally appeared on The Kitchn. See it there: Reese’s New Peanut Butter Cup Flavor Tastes Like the Best of Two Dessert Worlds (100x Better Than the Original)

Ali Domrongchai

Contributor

Ali Domrongchai, a Southern-raised, Brooklyn-based food writer, grew up around her family's Thai restaurant that sparked her initial love for food. (Fun fact: her grandparents briefly ran a Thai grocery store in the 70s). In this space, her curiosity on the role that food plays in building community lead her to pursue a Bachelor’s of Arts in American Studies with a focus on the ways in which pad Thai affects the Thai American experience at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.She joins The Kitchn as an Associate Editor for the Groceries vertical. Before this role, she held staff positions at Food & Wine, Travel + Leisure, and Allrecipes. Her words and recipes have also been featured in Cook's Country, Simply Recipes, and EatingWell. Oh, and most importantly, she can’t go more than a few hours without a sweet treat.

Get to know Ali Domrongchai
Related ContentSee All